Panel: Is Manny Pacquiao fighting Ryan Garcia a good idea?

Manny Pacquiao

Matthew Hatton
European champion

Itโ€™s really interesting. When you see the level Pacquiaoโ€™s boxed at for so long, itโ€™s phenomenal really. Would it be a passing of the torch? To be honest, Iโ€™d still back Pacquiao to win that, I think it could be a mistake for Garciaโ€™s people. I liked what I saw of Garcia against Luke Campbell, but whether heโ€™s ready for Pacquiao Iโ€™m not convinced.

Ryan Rhodes
Former world title challenger

I believe itโ€™s a good idea only for one person and thatโ€™s Manny Pacquiao, Ryan Garcia is not ready for the elite fighters just yet, he needs another two years to improve.

Mickey Helliet
Manager and promoter

Pacquiao vs Garcia is a very intriguing fight. I hope they use VADA testing to avoid the slurs on Pacquiao. Pacquiao is a known brand so probably the best payday but a dangerous puncher none the less. The old saying โ€the last thing to go is a fighterโ€™s punchโ€ could haunt Garcia who was heavily knocked down by Luke Campbell.

Declan Taylor
Sports journalist

I canโ€™t work out what the caveat is here. Garcia is a lightweight, Manny Pacquiao beat up a big welterweight Keith Thurman in his last fight. I really donโ€™t think this is a good idea for a 22-year-old 135lber. If Garcia wins itโ€™s colossal but thatโ€™s a big if.

Read our report on Ryan Garcia’s fight with Luke Campbell here

Share Page